×

Warning

JUser: :_load: Unable to load user with ID: 504

Notice

Thank you for visiting our website.

Please note that the site is not fully functional at the moment as we are in the process of re-developing. We hope that you will find the available resources helpful in the meantime.

German wasp | Vespula germanica

German wasp

Vespula germanica

Coral bush | Ardisia crenata

Coral bush

Ardisia crenata

Purple loosestrife | Lythrum salicaria

Purple loosestrife

Lythrum salicaria

Pom pom weed | Campuloclinium macrocephalum

Pom pom weed

Campuloclinium macrocephalum

Canarybird bush | Crotalaria agatiflora

Canarybird bush

Crotalaria agatiflora

Peanut butter cassia | Senna didymobotrya

Peanut butter cassia

Senna didymobotrya

Rubber vine | Cryptostegia grandiflora

Rubber vine

Cryptostegia grandiflora

1 2 3 4 5 6 7

Environmental Programmes

In order to tackle our country’s socio-economic challenges, the government adopted the Outcomes based approach to improve government performance and providing focus on service delivery. find out more

Scientific Assessments: matching the approach to the problem

||| ||| |||

Scientific Assessments: matching the approach to the problem
Robert J. Scholes
GCSRI, Wits

Scientific Assessments are a large part of the lives of many researchers. They aim to be an interface between science and society; and particularly between science and policy. As the nature of the problems demanding policy action becomes more and more technical and complex, so the need has arisen to have a process to collate and evaluate the relevant information, and then communicate it to policymakers, along with the associated uncertainties, in a clear fashion. There is a range of ways to conduct such assessments, which vary in how long they take, how many (and what type) of assessors they use, and how they engage with the users. The paper outlines some of the key attributes and success factors of several assessment approaches, and matches them to the circumstances where they are most likely to be successful.

Where the audience is other researchers, and the question being addressed is an emerging area in science, the scientific review is a well-established approach, taught at universities, and following certain conventions. It is performed by one or a few researchers, who cover a usually narrow area quite exhaustively. They tend to leave the assessment of what is reviewed to the reader. The approach is appropriate for an issue which is of scientific interest, but no great social prominence.

Where the science is relatively straightforward and well-established, and a quick but well-focused input to policy is needed, the ‘Briefing Note’ is a well-tested vehicle. It is typically written by one person, but benefits from both peer review, and an initial interactive process to define the scope. Brevity, focus and clarity are of the essence.

More complex issues, where the science may be difficult but is not in dispute are typically handled with a Contract Report: the team of experts is multidisciplinary but relatively small, and a single peer-review step is used.  Often new data is presented. A summarizing overview is helpful.

Where the public interest is high (and often polarized), the issue is complex (involving many sub-questions and disciplines, interactions and conditional outcomes) and the science is quite technical and often incompletely settled, the appropriate approach involves much greater two-way engagement with user groups for the assessors to understand policymaker’s needs, and for the policymakers to understand the strengths and limits of the science, and to participate in the selection of the expert teams. The opinion of the experts is actively but transparently sought; a multi-author team (often numbering hundreds) helps to provide a balanced assessment, along with extensive (repeated), documented and open review. A solid authorizing environment is critical for success. 

Read 3240 times Last modified on Tuesday, 03 May 2016 12:09

General News Updates

2019 National Symposium on Biological Invasio…

26-02-2019

This is your invitation to South Africa's 2019 National Symposium on Biological Invasions. The convention is hosted by the Centre for Invasion Biology (CIB), University of Stellenbosch, and the Biolo... Read more

2019 Invasive Species Training

22-01-2019

During the past five years (2014-2018), ISSA invasive species trainers have trained 4 000 in the identification of invasive species and laws pertaining to invasive species across South Africa.  ... Read more

Alien Grass Working Group

04-09-2018

Who are we? The South African National Alien Grass Working Group was jointly initiated by the South African Biodiversity Institute (SANBI) and the Centre for Excellence in Invasion Biology (C·I·B) in... Read more

Permits for planting indigenous Cynodon?

01-03-2018

On 16 February, 2018, South Africa's Department of Environmental Affairs issued amendments to the regulations and lists relating to the National List of Invasive Species.  Updates to the draft&n... Read more

Invasive species training 2018 dates released

28-02-2018

Interested in invasive species?  How much do you know about NEMBA invasive species compliance for landowners and organs of state? The South African Green Industries Council (SAGIC) have released... Read more

Communications post for Africa advertised

25-01-2018

The Nature Conservancy has advertised a brand new post:  Communications Manager, Africa Region. Knowledge of invasive species and water would be an asset in this post. See details below:    Job Titl... Read more